FCA rulings

The Supreme Court car finance ruling explained

In August 2025 the Supreme Court largely sided with lenders, but found one customer’s relationship unfair. That decision shaped the FCA’s compensation scheme, which is now facing a legal challenge.

The Supreme Court did not rule that car finance customers were owed money across the board. On 1 August 2025 it overturned most of the Court of Appeal’s pro-consumer decision. But it found that one customer, Mr Johnson, had an unfair relationship with his lender under the Consumer Credit Act. That narrower finding is what the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) used to design its compensation scheme.

Update, 3 October 2026: The FCA confirmed its final scheme rules on 30 March 2026. On 2 July 2026 the Upper Tribunal suspended parts of the scheme while it hears legal challenges, now due to be heard on 16 to 26 February 2027. Lenders do not currently have to calculate or pay compensation under the scheme. The FCA says that if the scheme is upheld, payments should begin in 2027.

The three cases

The judgment, [2025] UKSC 33, dealt with three appeals heard together: Hopcraft v Close Brothers, Johnson v FirstRand Bank (trading as MotoNovo Finance) and Wrench v FirstRand Bank. In each, a customer bought a car through a dealer who also arranged the finance and received commission from the lender.

In October 2024 the Court of Appeal had decided in the customers’ favour. It found that dealers owed customers duties that commission arrangements could breach. The lenders appealed.

What the Supreme Court decided

The court rejected the main legal routes the customers relied on.

  • No fiduciary duty. A dealer arranging finance is dealing at arm’s length with its own commercial aims. It does not take on a duty of “single-minded loyalty” to the customer.
  • No bribery claim. The court confirmed the old law on bribes and secret commissions still exists, but it needs a fiduciary relationship. Without one, those claims failed.

So the lenders won their appeals in Hopcraft and Wrench in full. The court also said that a lack of disclosure, on its own, will not necessarily make a relationship unfair.

Why Mr Johnson still won

Mr Johnson bought a second-hand Suzuki Swift on hire purchase. He also brought a claim under section 140A of the Consumer Credit Act 1974, which lets a court reopen an unfair lender relationship. The Supreme Court upheld that claim for three reasons:

  • the commission of £1,650.95 was large, at about 25% of the amount borrowed and 55% of the total charge for credit
  • the documents gave a false impression of how independent the dealer’s choice of lender was, and hid a commercial tie between dealer and lender
  • he was commercially unsophisticated

The court ordered that the commission be paid to Mr Johnson with interest.

How it shaped the FCA scheme

On 3 August 2025 the FCA said it would consult on a compensation scheme. It estimated most people would receive less than £950 per agreement.

The final rules, published on 30 March 2026, follow the unfair relationship approach. The scheme covers regulated motor finance agreements taken out between 6 April 2007 and 1 November 2024 where the customer was not told about a discretionary commission arrangement, a high commission or a contractual tie between lender and dealer. The FCA estimates about 12.1 million agreements are eligible, with an average payout of around £830 per agreement.

The FCA’s consumer guidance explains the scheme rules in more detail, and our article on who is eligible for car finance compensation summarises them.

What you can do now

The FCA’s advice is to complain directly to your lender if you’re concerned. It is free, and the FCA warns that using a claims firm or law firm could cost you around 30% of any compensation. You don’t need anyone to act for you.

Where tax comes in

Compensation under the scheme includes interest, paid at the Bank of England base rate plus 1% a year, with a minimum of 3%. The Supreme Court also awarded Mr Johnson interest. That interest is taxed as savings income, and the lender usually deducts basic-rate income tax (22% from 6 April 2027) before paying you.

Many people don’t owe that tax, because of the Personal Savings Allowance or because they’re non-taxpayers. If so, some or all of it can be reclaimed from HMRC, usually on an R40. Our how it works page explains how we check your position and make the claim for you.

Next step

If you’ve already received compensation, find the lender’s letter showing the tax deducted and try our eligibility calculator. It gives a general estimate. Your own tax position for the year decides the final figure.

Sources

Ready when you are

Get back what your lender kept.

Been paid? See what you could get back in about a minute. Still waiting for your lender? Reserve your rebate and we’ll be ready the day they pay.

Calculate my rebate Not paid yet? Reserve
Calculate my rebate